Rubbermaid Extra Large Deck Box Review: The 134-Gallon Model, Checked

The Rubbermaid Extra Large Deck Box, sold on Amazon as the Extra Large Resin Outdoor Storage Deck Box, is a 134 gallon box for patio cushions, pool gear and garden tools. The lid doubles as a seat or a side table. It is Rubbermaid’s current extra large model. It replaced the 120 gallon version this page used to cover, which Amazon now lists as unavailable.

It holds a lot and carries a 10-year warranty. Amazon owners are less sure about how well it keeps water out and how long it lasts, so read the owner feedback before you buy.

How we reviewed it: this review is based on Rubbermaid’s product page, assembly manual and warranty document, the Amazon listing, and owner feedback on Amazon, checked in October 2026. More on our process.

Rubbermaid Extra Large Deck Box, 134 gallon

Quick Verdict

Buy it if you want a big cushion box from a known brand with a 10-year warranty, and you can keep it on level ground under some cover. Owners like the space: almost nobody on Amazon complains about storage capacity.

Be careful if it will sit in open rain or you want it to last many seasons. Amazon owners split on water resistance, and most who mention durability or value for money are unhappy. For a box with stronger owner ratings at a similar size, see our Lifetime 60012 review.

Rubbermaid Extra Large Deck Box Specifications

Models2145549 (gray); 2119055 (brown); catalog number 2P37
Capacity134 gallons (about 17.9 cubic feet)
Exterior (W x D x H)55.5 x 27.5 x 26.8 in
Box weight51.9 lb
MaterialDouble-wall resin; metal lid support
LidFlat, textured top for seating or serving; lockable (lock sold separately)
AssemblyRequired; 6 steps, hardware included
Warranty10-year limited, prorated (see below)
Sources: Rubbermaid.com product page, assembly manual and 10-year warranty document; Amazon listing. Checked October 2026.

What Fits Inside

134 gallons is roughly 18 cubic feet. Rubbermaid pitches it for patio umbrellas, large cushions, firewood, pool accessories and garden tools. In the Amazon reviews, which also cover the smaller Medium, one owner stores the seat and back cushions for four chairs, and another fits a Weber portable grill table.

One owner also points out that it has no handles or wheels. At 51.9 lb empty, pick its spot before you load it.

Is It Waterproof?

No. The Amazon listing calls it water resistant and says the lid design keeps water out. Owners can’t agree. Some report a dry box after heavy rain. Others say water gets in, and one owner notes the seams meet edge to edge rather than overlapping.

If you store cushions, give it some cover, keep it off low spots where water pools, and don’t put anything in it that rust or mildew would ruin. Rubbermaid’s manual says to keep the lid closed and secured when you’re not using it, and to clear snow and debris off the top.

Can You Sit on It?

Rubbermaid says the lid gives you seating or serving space, and a metal lid support is there to stop warping from weather or weight. Rubbermaid does not publish a weight limit for the lid. The manual says not to stand on the box, not to put hot items in or on it, and warns that it can get hot in direct sun.

Assembly

Rubbermaid says this model has 67% fewer parts than its earlier extra large deck box. The manual shows four main panels (front, back, floor and lid), a lid support, three hinges, connector brackets and pins, 15 screws and 6 lock nuts, put together in six steps. You need a Phillips screwdriver or drill, a 7/16 in wrench or ratchet, safety glasses and gloves. Don’t overtighten the screws. The manual says this more than once.

Assembly draws more complaints than praise. Some say most of it is sliding panels together. Others call it hard to put together with poor instructions, and a few mention dented panels or missing parts. One owner suggests swapping the hinge screws for stainless steel because the originals rusted.

The 10-Year Warranty

Rubbermaid’s 10-year limited warranty names two versions of this box: the gray 2145549 and the brown 2119055. Amazon also sells a charcoal version, model 2193949, which is not on that list. Rubbermaid notes that unlisted deck boxes may come with its standard 1-year warranty, so check before you buy that color.

The coverage is prorated. If a part is defective, Rubbermaid replaces that part. If the whole box needs replacing, Rubbermaid either replaces it or refunds the purchase price minus 10% for each year you’ve owned it. After 7 years, that refund is 30%. You need proof of purchase. The warranty does not cover:

  • Damage from wind, hail, storms, heavy snow, ice, flood or fire
  • Setting it up on an un-level surface, or assembling it in a way the manual doesn’t describe
  • Fading, normal wear, overloading, or any repair or modification
  • Commercial use, or use outside the US and Canada

What Amazon Owners Say

Amazon pools reviews of this box with the 74 gallon Medium in the same style, so they cover both sizes. The listing’s “Customers say” summary (checked October 2026) sorts owner comments by topic:

  • Mostly praised: storage capacity and size.
  • Leaning positive: quality.
  • Split: water resistance and sturdiness.
  • Leaning negative: assembly.
  • Mostly negative: durability and value for money.

People like how much it holds. Many think it costs too much for what it is: some call the plastic thin and say it warps in the sun, and several expect it to last only a couple of seasons.

The Older 120 Gallon Extra Large

If you are looking for the box this page used to review, that was the 120 gallon Extra Large Deck Box with Seat, model 2047052 (catalog number 5E39). Rubbermaid still has a page for it, but its Amazon listing shows it as unavailable. Here is how the two compare:

Older Rubbermaid 120 gallon Extra Large deck box, model 2047052
The older 120 gallon Extra Large (2047052). This is not the 134 gallon box reviewed above.
Current XL (2145549)Older XL (2047052)
Capacity134 gallons120 gallons
Exterior (W x D x H)55.5 x 27.5 x 26.8 in60 x 25.97 x 27.69 in
Box weight51.9 lb56 lb
Warranty10-year limited10-year limited
On AmazonAvailableUnavailable
Sources: Rubbermaid.com product pages and 10-year warranty document; Amazon listings. Checked October 2026.
Scale drawing of the Rubbermaid 134 gallon and 120 gallon Extra Large deck boxes, front and top views with exterior dimensions
Both boxes drawn to the same scale from Rubbermaid’s exterior dimensions.

These numbers look odd side by side, and they are Rubbermaid’s own. The newer box is smaller on the outside: 4.5 inches narrower and almost an inch lower, though 1.5 inches deeper. Yet Rubbermaid rates it for 14 more gallons. Rubbermaid does not publish interior dimensions for the 134 gallon model, so we can’t confirm that figure. If you are buying for a specific load, such as a set of cushions, measure it against the exterior size and allow for the double walls.

Amazon’s listing for the older model says it has a 1-year warranty, but Rubbermaid’s own warranty document lists 2047052 under the 10-year coverage.

Rubbermaid XL vs. Lifetime 60012

The Lifetime 60012 is the obvious alternative at this size. Both have a 10-year limited warranty and weigh about the same. The differences:

Rubbermaid XLLifetime 60012
Capacity134 gallons130 gallons
Exterior (W x D x H)55.5 x 27.5 x 26.8 in60 x 24 x 26.3 in
Published weight ratingNone900 lb for the unit
Sources: Rubbermaid.com; Lifetime.com. Checked October 2026.

The Rubbermaid is 4.5 inches shorter end to end, which helps on a tight patio. The Lifetime has a published weight rating and far more owner ratings, at a higher average.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • 134 gallons in a 55.5 in wide footprint
  • 10-year limited warranty on the gray and brown models
  • Double-wall resin with a metal lid support
  • Flat lid works as a seat or side table
  • Fewer parts than Rubbermaid’s earlier XL box

Cons

  • Water resistant, not waterproof, and owners are split on leaks
  • Weak owner scores for durability and value for money
  • No published weight rating for the lid
  • No handles or wheels
  • Warranty is prorated and excludes weather damage

Who Should Buy It, and Who Should Skip It

Buy it if you want maximum capacity in a box that fits a narrow deck or patio, and it will sit under an overhang or covered porch.

Skip it if it will stand in open weather all year, or you want a lid rated for regular seating. Our Lifetime 60012 review covers a 130 gallon box with a published weight rating. Our deck box buying guide explains what to compare, and the best outdoor deck boxes roundup lists more options.

Final Verdict

The Rubbermaid Extra Large Deck Box gives you a lot of space for its footprint and a long warranty on paper. Owner feedback is more mixed than the star rating suggests, especially on leaks, durability and value. Buy the gray or brown model so the 10-year warranty applies, keep it level and under some cover, and treat it as water resistant, not waterproof.

Frequently Asked Questions

How big is the Rubbermaid Extra Large deck box?

It holds 134 gallons, about 17.9 cubic feet. Rubbermaid lists it at 55.5 x 27.5 x 26.8 inches and 51.9 lb.

Is the Rubbermaid Extra Large deck box waterproof?

No. It is sold as water resistant. Amazon owners are split on whether it stays dry inside, so keep it under cover if you store cushions.

Can you sit on the Rubbermaid deck box?

Rubbermaid says the lid offers seating space and has a metal lid support, but it does not publish a weight limit. The manual says not to stand on it.

What warranty does the Rubbermaid Extra Large deck box have?

A 10-year limited warranty for the gray 2145549 and brown 2119055. Full replacements are prorated at 10% per year, and weather damage, un-level setup and fading are not covered.

What is the difference between the 120 and 134 gallon Rubbermaid deck boxes?

The 134 gallon model (2145549) is the current Extra Large. It is 55.5 inches wide and rated for 14 gallons more than the older 120 gallon model (2047052), which is 60 inches wide and unavailable on Amazon. The newer box is smaller on the outside, and Rubbermaid does not publish its interior dimensions.

Does the Rubbermaid deck box lock?

Yes. It is lockable, but the lock is sold separately.

Storage Sheds HQ logo

Storage Sheds HQ Editorial Team

Reviews & Buying Guides

We review sheds and deck boxes from manufacturer specifications, warranty terms and assembly documentation, cross-checked against owner feedback at scale. Read more on our About page.

Storage Sheds HQ is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.