Suncast BMS2500 Horizontal Shed Review: Size, Trash Can Fit and Setup

The Suncast BMS2500 is a 34 cubic foot horizontal shed: a resin box 53 inches wide and under 4 feet tall, with a lift-up lid and two front doors. Suncast sells it for trash cans, garden gear and bikes. The measurements tell a narrower story. It holds two small 32 gallon carts, cushions or yard tools well, but it is too shallow for the 64 and 96 gallon wheeled carts that many haulers issue. Like every current Suncast shed, it also needs a slab or wood platform underneath, and the warranty depends on it.

How we reviewed it: this review is based on Suncast’s BMS2500 product pages, dimension drawing and assembly manual, Suncast’s warranty, Toter’s cart specifications, and the Amazon and Home Depot listings with their owner feedback, checked in November 2026. More on our process.

The Short Answer

Buy the BMS2500 if you want low storage along a wall or fence for small trash cans, patio cushions, a generator or garden supplies, and you can build a level base for it. It is under 4 feet tall, opens from the top and the front, and locks with one padlock. Skip it if the job is hiding full-size wheeled trash carts. Those need the bigger Suncast Stow-Away BMS4720.

Suncast BMS2500 Dimensions and Specs

Capacity34 cu ft
Exterior53 in wide x 32.5 in deep x 45.5 in high (4 ft 5 in x 2 ft 8.5 in x 3 ft 9.5 in)
Interior49 in wide x 28.25 in deep; 40 in high at the front, 43.5 in at the back
Door opening46.25 in wide x 40.25 in high
Floor area9.6 sq ft inside
AccessLift-up lid held by a prop rod, plus two front doors
LockingOne padlock through the hasp secures the lid and both doors (5/16 in lock, not included)
ConstructionMulti-wall resin panels with a reinforced floor; water resistant, not waterproof
Weight76 lb, per the Amazon listing
Made inUSA
Warranty10-year limited
Sources: Suncast BMS2500 product page, dimension drawing and assembly manual; Amazon listing B007H6PEA6. Checked November 2026.

One figure needs a note. Suncast’s BMS2500 page gives the inside depth as 2 ft 2.25 in. Its dimension drawing, and its page for the same shed in another color, both give 2 ft 4.25 in, which is 28.25 inches. We have used the drawing.

Scale drawing of the Suncast BMS2500 horizontal shed, 53 inches wide, 32.5 inches deep and 45.5 inches high, with two 32 gallon trash carts inside and a list showing that 48 gallon carts do not fit wheels first and 64 and 96 gallon carts do not fit
The BMS2500 drawn to scale from Suncast’s figures, with two 32 gallon carts inside.

The lid slopes. Suncast’s drawing shows 40 inches of height inside at the front and 43.5 inches at the back, where the lid is hinged.

Colors and Model Numbers

Suncast sells this shed under three model numbers. They are the same size and share one assembly manual.

  • BMS2500: vanilla with a stoney lid. This is the one on Amazon.
  • BMS2500SB: stoney with a black lid.
  • BMS3400X: sand with a slate lid.

Will Your Trash Cans Fit?

Suncast’s page says the shed is ideal for garbage cans. That is true of small ones. We checked the inside against Toter’s published sizes for its two-wheel carts, a common make of curbside cart.

Cart sizeDoes it fit?
32 gallon
24.25 in deep, 19.75 in wide, 37.5 in high
Yes. Two stand side by side: 39.5 inches of cart in a 46.25 inch door opening.
48 gallon
28.75 in deep, 23.5 in wide, 37.5 in high
Only turned sideways. Wheels first, it is half an inch deeper than the 28.25 inch interior. Sideways it fits, but you can no longer roll it straight in and out.
64 gallon
31.75 in deep, 24.25 in wide, 41.75 in high
No. It is too deep, and taller than the 40.25 inch door opening.
96 gallon
35.75 in deep, 29.75 in wide, 43.25 in high
No. It is too deep and too tall.
Cart sizes from Toter cart sales sheet (2024). Shed sizes from Suncast’s drawing.

Carts vary by maker, so measure yours, including the handle and the lid hinge, before you order. If you have 64 or 96 gallon carts, the Stow-Away BMS4720 is the Suncast shed sized for them.

What Else Fits

The floor is reinforced, and Suncast says it supports heavier items and equipment, though it does not publish a weight limit. Its page lists lawn and garden products, snow blowers and bicycles. Check two of those against the tape measure:

  • Snow blowers and mowers: the machine has to pass through a 46.25 inch wide, 40.25 inch high door opening and sit within 28.25 inches of depth.
  • Bikes: the inside is 49 inches wide. A full-size adult bike is usually longer than that, so this shed suits children’s bikes and scooters better.

Cushions, a hose reel, bags of soil and pool supplies are the easy cases. The lid lifts and rests on a prop rod, which lets you reach in from above without opening the doors.

No shelf is included. The manual has a template for one optional shelf: a board 50 inches by 12 inches, cut from 3/4 inch wood and fixed with two screws. Suncast also lists a shelf kit (BMSASHELFH1), baskets and tool hangers as compatible accessories.

BMS2500 Foundation: Slab or Wood Platform

The manual says site preparation and a foundation are required before assembly, and puts it in four words: warranty requires foundation. It approves two kinds.

  • Concrete slab: a single slab at least 4 inches thick. Reinforcement bar is recommended.
  • Wood platform: pressure-treated 2×6 lumber on deck blocks or footings, topped with a 3/4 inch board cut to 31.5 x 51.5 inches. A bigger platform is fine as long as the shed sits centered on those dimensions.

Either way the site has to be graded, compacted and level, with the ground sloping away for drainage. On an uneven base, the manual warns, the shed will not assemble correctly. Our guide to choosing a shed site covers drainage and clearances.

How to Anchor the BMS2500

After assembly, the shed must be secured to the foundation. On concrete, use four 3/8 inch masonry anchors with 1 inch washers. On a wood platform, use four 3 inch lag screws with 1 inch washers, lined up with the framing underneath. The hardware is not included. At 76 lb the shed is light, so do not skip this step and rely on what is stored inside.

BMS2500 Assembly

Suncast’s page says assembly needs minimal tools, and the manual’s cover says assistance is required. The side panels slide and lock into the floor, and the manual suggests a rubber mallet to push them home. It also tells you to check every part against the parts pages first and not to build in bad weather.

Owner feedback on Amazon is split here. Some found the shed easy to put together and others found it difficult, and the instructions are the one topic Amazon’s summary rates negative overall.

Placement and Care

  • Keep it away from gutters and downspouts. Suncast says it is water resistant, not waterproof.
  • Keep it away from hot objects and highly reflective surfaces. The manual singles out Low-E windows, which reflect more heat than standard glass.
  • Do not lean heavy items against the walls, and do not stand, sit or store things on the roof.
  • Do not store flammable, caustic or corrosive materials in it.
  • Clean it with mild soap and water, not caustic cleaners or stiff brushes. Staining from skipped cleaning is not covered by the warranty.
  • Check now and then that it is still level, and keep the roof clear of snow and leaves.

What Owners Say

Amazon’s summary of owner reviews for this listing (checked November 2026) sorts comments by topic:

  • Mostly praised: storage capacity, appearance and how well it does its job.
  • Mixed: assembly, quality, value for money and fit.
  • Mostly negative: the instructions.

Owners use it for children’s outdoor toys, pool supplies, gardening tools and trash cans. On the fit complaints, the manual’s own warning is worth repeating: on a base that is not flat and level, it says, the shed will not assemble correctly.

At Home Depot, the BMS2500 shows 4.2 out of 5 from 209 reviews, and the BMS2500SB shows 4.0 out of 5 from 120 reviews (checked November 2026).

BMS2500 Warranty Conditions

Suncast gives its blow-molded sheds, the models starting BMS, a 10-year limited warranty that runs from the delivery date. It covers repair or replacement of parts that fail from a manufacturing or materials defect, for the original buyer only. The conditions matter more than the term:

  • Register within 90 days with a copy of your receipt. Registration is not required in California and Connecticut.
  • Build the foundation and anchor the shed as the manual describes.
  • Keep it latched and padlocked whenever it is not in use.
  • Buy new from Suncast or an authorized seller. The BMS2500 on Amazon is sold and shipped by Amazon.com.

Suncast’s warranty page says that when those conditions are met, its outdoor storage sheds are rated to withstand winds up to 65 mph. Damage from wind and other weather is still excluded from cover, so treat the rating as a design figure, not a promise to pay.

How It Compares

ShedHow it differs
Suncast Stow-Away BMS472070 cu ft, 70.5 inches wide. Sized for two 96 gallon carts, with a gas-shock lid.
Suncast Glidetop BMS495098 cu ft, with a lid that slides back instead of lifting.
Rubbermaid Large Horizontal32 cu ft and 60 inches wide, with a 1-year warranty.
Suncast BMS5700The same 53 x 32.5 inch footprint, but 71.5 inches tall, for long-handled tools.

The BMS2500 took over from older Suncast boxes that are no longer made. If you are replacing one, see our pages on the Suncast GS17500 and the Suncast GS1000. Every shed we have reviewed is listed on our reviews page.

Final Word

The BMS2500 is a compact, lockable box with a 10-year warranty that opens from the top and the front. It suits small cans, cushions and garden gear along a wall. It does not suit full-size trash carts or adult bikes, whatever the product page suggests. Build the slab or platform first, anchor the shed, register it within 90 days and keep a padlock on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the Suncast BMS2500 dimensions?

53 inches wide, 32.5 inches deep and 45.5 inches high outside. Inside it is 49 inches wide and 28.25 inches deep, with 40 inches of height at the front and 43.5 inches at the back.

How big is the Suncast BMS2500 door opening?

46.25 inches wide and 40.25 inches high. The lid also lifts for access from the top.

Will a 96 gallon trash can fit in the Suncast BMS2500?

No. A typical 96 gallon cart is 35.75 inches deep and 43.25 inches tall, and the shed is 28.25 inches deep inside with a 40.25 inch door opening. Two typical 32 gallon carts fit.

Will a 64 gallon trash can fit in the Suncast BMS2500?

No. A typical 64 gallon cart is 31.75 inches deep and 41.75 inches tall, and the shed is 28.25 inches deep inside with a 40.25 inch high door opening. The Stow-Away BMS4720 is the Suncast shed sized for 64 and 96 gallon carts.

Does the Suncast BMS2500 need a foundation?

Yes. The manual requires a concrete slab at least 4 inches thick or a wood platform on deck blocks or footings, and says the warranty requires the foundation.

Does the Suncast BMS2500 lock?

Yes. One padlock through the hasp secures the lid and both doors. The manual calls for a 5/16 inch lock, which is not included.

What is the difference between the BMS2500 and the BMS3400X?

Color only. The BMS2500 is vanilla with a stoney lid, the BMS2500SB is stoney with a black lid, and the BMS3400X is sand with a slate lid. All three are the same size and share one manual.

Is the Suncast BMS2500 waterproof?

No. Suncast calls it water resistant, not waterproof, and says to place it away from gutters and downspouts.

What is the warranty on the Suncast BMS2500?

A 10-year limited warranty for the original buyer. You must register within 90 days, build the foundation, anchor the shed and keep it padlocked when not in use.

Storage Sheds HQ logo

Storage Sheds HQ Editorial Team

Reviews & Buying Guides

We review sheds from manufacturer specifications, warranty terms and assembly documentation, cross-checked against owner feedback at scale. Read more on our About page.

Storage Sheds HQ is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.